Page 1 of 1
Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Fri Jan 28, 2022 12:11 pm
by Canadman
Ok, since I'm still waiting for the snow to melt to get to restoring my S2a 88 (yes, I closed in my garage so now my restoration project will be an outdoor one - I just like to make life more difficult for myself), I have time on my hands so I thought, being that it's Friday, it would be a good time for stupid, non-mechanic question of the week.
I have LOTS of tools... including MANY, MANY wrenches (spanners), sockets, etc etc... I keep reading everywhere that a Land Rover restoration would be severely impaired without a good set of Whitworth wrenches (spanners) on hand. My question is why, exactly? Would not standard metric and imperial wrenches work? If not, what is it about Whitworth wrenches that makes them so different from others?
Also, for bonus points, has anyone tried these induction heat bolt removers (vs propane torches)?
Please carry on with any scoffing, eye-rolling or general horror at my (what will soon to prove to be ongoing) lack of mechanical expertise and knowledge.
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Fri Jan 28, 2022 1:14 pm
by harv
Whitworth wrenches are a different size than SAE or Metric. Having said that, I had my 88” 2A for 27 years and did almost every job possible with my SAE and Metric tools. Sometimes I needed to tap my sockets on but I never owned a Whitworth tool.
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Fri Jan 28, 2022 4:49 pm
by red90
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Fri Jan 28, 2022 7:44 pm
by oldgravy
I bought a cheap set of whitworth spanners in a combo with whitworth sockets off of Amazon. It wasn't that expensive.
On my S2 the axle flange bolts and the bearing cap bolts in the differential have been whitworth. I tried getting the axle flange bolts off with a crescent wrench, but that didn't work.
You could just drill + chisel or grind the bolts off, but then you'd have to find suitable replacements of the correct dimensions and grade in either metric or sae.
It's all possible. Or you could just spend the $40 like I did.
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Sat Jan 29, 2022 7:54 am
by John
Because you can never have too many tools, but, as others have said, you can probably make do without. Induction heaters are great but pricey. They can also be used in areas where an open flame may not be the most practical thing. If you are a sawzall or cutting torch kind of guy then they are probably not the tool for you though. Enjoy your restoration.
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Sat Jan 29, 2022 9:06 am
by RobinS
During my restoration I found many instances where a standard or metric wrench would work however some are purely whitworth and not having the correct whitworth wrench or socket would end up in rounded off fasteners so I purchased a quality set from amazon.
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Sun Jan 30, 2022 10:04 am
by Colin
Series transmission use Whiteworth sized nuts, the rest of the truck will be SAE or metric, or a mix.
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Mon Jan 31, 2022 5:36 am
by RobinS
On my series one I had engine , driveline and swivel pin fittings which were whitworth and several bolts on the body fittings which were whitworth also. maybe the later series used more standard .
Re: Whitworth Wrenches - Why?
Posted: Mon Jan 31, 2022 8:07 am
by Canadman
I decided to just go ahead and buy some Whitworth spanners. Didn't get the sockets, but hopefully the spanners will suffice.